Comparative Analysis Of HCP Clearance Performance Of Protein A Membrane Chromatography
Aug 11, 2026| As an alternative to traditional resin-based chromatography columns, Protein A membrane chromatography has gained significant attention in antibody capture applications in recent years. Its advantages, including high throughput, low pressure drop, and single-use capability, have been widely recognized. However, regarding the HCP (Host Cell Protein) clearance performance of Protein A membranes, the literature has presented contradictory conclusions: Gehrmann et al. (2024) reported that membranes outperformed resins, whereas Pasquier et al. (2025) concluded that resins consistently demonstrated superior performance compared with membranes. So, which conclusion is correct? Recently, the downstream process development team at WuXi Biologics published a short communication in Protein Expression and Purification entitled "Deciphering the Inconsistent Performance of Protein A Membrane on Host Cell Protein Clearance." Based on 10 projects covering monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), bispecific antibodies (BsAbs), trispecific antibodies (TsAbs), and Fc-fusion proteins, the study systematically compared the HCP clearance performance of Protein A membranes and MabSelect SuRe LX resin. Furthermore, the authors proposed a concise yet powerful mechanistic model to explain the observed discrepancies.This article provides an in-depth interpretation of this study.
I. The Root Cause of the Discrepancy: Biased Conclusions Caused by Insufficient Sample Size
The contradictory conclusions drawn by the two previous studies can be primarily attributed to their insufficient sample sizes. Gehrmann et al. concluded that membranes outperform resins based on only one case study, while Pasquier et al. concluded that resins outperform membranes based on only two cases. Considering the significant differences in HCP profiles and HCP–antibody interaction patterns among different molecules, such limited sample sizes are clearly insufficient to support generalizable conclusions.
The research team adopted a more robust experimental design: harvest cell culture fluids from 10 different projects, including four monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), four bispecific antibodies (BsAbs), one trispecific antibody (TsAb), and one Fc-fusion protein, were processed using Protein A membranes and MabSelect SuRe LX chromatography columns under their respective standard operating conditions. The HCP levels in the eluates were then compared.
Ⅱ.Key Data: In 9 out of 10 cases, the Protein A membrane showed better or comparable HCP clearance performance compared with the resin.
The experimental results (Table 1) clearly demonstrate the performance of the two media across different molecules.:

The yield and host cell protein (HCP) data of Protein A chromatography columns and membrane chromatography eluates from the ten case studies.

Key Conclusion: Among the 10 case studies, the HCP levels in the Protein A membrane eluates were lower than or comparable to those in the resin column eluates in 9 cases. However, bsAb C was a clear exception, where the HCP level in the resin eluate was 8,631 ppm, while the membrane eluate showed a much higher HCP level of 11,164 ppm.
III. Mechanistic Explanation Model: High Flow Rate Is a "Double-Edged Sword
Why does the membrane perform better in most cases but worse in some specific cases? The authors proposed a concise explanatory framework: the high flow rate (short residence time) of Protein A membranes is a "double-edged sword"-it can reduce HCP co-purification, but it can also negatively affect HCP clearance under certain conditions.

Schematic Illustration of the Double-Edged Sword Effect of High Flow Rate in Protein A Membrane Chromatography for Host Cell Protein (HCP) Removal
Beneficial Effect - Elution Stage: Reduced HCP Leaching
According to the study by Gagnon et al., the harvest cell culture fluid contains chromatin heteroaggregates composed of DNA–histone cores, non-histone HCPs, and misfolded antibodies. After these aggregates bind to Protein A ligands, the associated HCPs can be released during the low-pH elution process. These chromatin aggregates are considered one of the major sources of HCPs in Protein A eluates.
The high flow rate of the membrane (with a typical residence time of 12 seconds) shortens the exposure time of heteroaggregates to low pH conditions, thereby reducing HCP leaching from these aggregates. The authors validated this hypothesis using a Protein A chromatography column: after loading the same Tri specific antibody harvest cell culture fluid, increasing the elution flow rate (reducing the residence time from 5 minutes to 0.3 minutes) decreased the HCP level in the eluate from 9,252 ppm to 3,381 ppm, representing an approximately 63% reduction.
Negative Effect - Washing Stage: Impaired HCP–Antibody Dissociation
Another major mechanism contributing to HCP co-purification is the direct interaction between HCPs and the target antibody. To address this mechanism, the commonly adopted strategy is to disrupt HCP–antibody interactions by optimizing washing conditions, such as applying high-pH wash steps or adding sodium caprylate.
However, the authors found that for bsAb C, neither high-pH washing nor sodium caprylate washing was effective under the standard membrane flow rate (5 MV/min, residence time of 12 seconds). In contrast, the same optimization strategies showed significant improvement when applied to the chromatography column (residence time of 5 minutes), reducing HCP levels from 8,631 ppm to 4,116 ppm with sodium caprylate washing.
This comparison reveals the key issue: the short residence time of the membrane prevents washing additives from having sufficient time to exert their effects. When strong interactions exist between HCPs and antibodies, the high flow rate can instead become a barrier to effective HCP removal.
IV. Solution Strategy: Reduce Flow Rate During Washing While Maintaining High Flow Rates for Other Steps
Based on the above understanding, the authors proposed a targeted strategy: a low flow rate is applied during the washing step, while maintaining the intrinsically high flow rate of the membrane during all other process steps.

When the flow rate of the second washing step was reduced from 5 MV/min to 0.2 MV/min (increasing the residence time from 12 seconds to 5 minutes), the HCP level in the bsAb C membrane eluate:
Under the platform washing condition: the HCP level decreased from 11,164 ppm to 6,763 ppm, representing an approximately 39% reduction;
Under the sodium octanoate washing condition: the HCP level decreased from 10,062 ppm to 4,242 ppm, representing an approximately 58% reduction.
It is worth noting that even under the platform washing condition (with unoptimized buffer composition), simply increasing the washing residence time reduced HCP by nearly 40%. This indicates that for molecules such as bsAb C, which exhibit strong HCP–antibody interactions, a sufficiently long washing time itself is an effective approach for HCP clearance.
Elution stage: Low flow rate / prolonged exposure to low pH → increased HCP leaching; high flow rate / short exposure time → reduced HCP leaching.
Washing stage: Low flow rate / prolonged exposure to high salt concentration and high pH conditions → promotes HCP–antibody dissociation; high flow rate / short exposure time → inhibits HCP–antibody dissociation.
VI. Summary and Process Implications
Protein A membranes generally demonstrate superior HCP clearance compared with resins. Among the 10 cases evaluated, 9 supported this conclusion, which is consistent with the proposed mechanism that high throughput reduces HCP leaching during elution. However, exceptions do exist. When strong interactions occur between HCPs and the target antibody, the standard high-flow-rate washing conditions of the membrane may be insufficient to disrupt these interactions, requiring a differentiated process strategy.
Recommended process strategy: Apply a low flow rate during the washing step (e.g., a residence time of 5 minutes), while maintaining high flow rates during other process steps (e.g., a residence time of 12 seconds). This approach enables optimal HCP clearance without sacrificing the membrane's inherent high-throughput advantage.
Implications for process development: This study explains the reasons behind conflicting conclusions reported in the literature and provides a practical optimization strategy. For teams evaluating Protein A membranes, it is recommended to optimize the washing flow rate and buffer composition based on the HCP interaction profile of the target molecule, rather than simply applying conclusions from previous literature.
One-sentence summary: The HCP clearance capability of Protein A membranes represents a balance between "elution protection" and "insufficient washing." By reducing the washing flow rate, membranes can achieve HCP clearance comparable to or even better than resins while maintaining their high-throughput advantage.

